Shalom Life | May 25, 2015

The Controversial Legacy of Charlotte Whitton

Jewish groups say Ottawa's first female mayor shouldn't be honoured due to her anti-Semitism.

By: Sammy Hudes

Published: August 18th, 2010 in News » World

The Controversial Legacy of Charlotte Whitton

Before Charlotte Whitton became the first female mayor of Ottawa in 1951, she served as the director of the Canadian Council on Child Welfare (CCCW) for over two decades early on in her career. As director, her job was to help improve the lives of countless needy and immigrant children. However, many argue that Whitton did the exact opposite by denying European Jewish refugee orphans into Canada during the Holocaust era, based solely on the fact that they were Jewish. This ultimately led to many children succumbing to Hitler’s wrath.

“Here’s a woman who really poisoned the well because after she did this, no Jewish orphans came into Canada and I believe it is a direct result of her anti-Semitism,” Bernie Farber, CEO of the Canadian Jewish Congress (CJC) told Shalom Life. “We are absolutely convinced of two things: Firstly, that she not be honoured in any way, given the fact that she was clearly an anti-Semite. She did poison the well and Jewish children were killed as a result of her lobbying against them finding shelter in this country. Secondly, I think it’s opened a wider question how do we in fact best commemorate national historic figures, when nobody’s really perfect in this world? How do we find the balance between the good and the bad? I think that’s a national discussion that has to be held.”

Due to Whitton’s actions, the CJC labeled her “an enemy of Jewish immigration”. Oscar Cohen of the CJC once said that she “almost broke up the inaugural meeting of the Canadian National Committee for Refugees (CNCR) by her insistent opposition and very apparent anti-Semitism.”

In addition to Jews, Whitton also reportedly viewed Armenians as “undesirable” immigrants. While serving as Ottawa’s mayor in 1964, she refused a half-million-dollar donation to the Civic Hospital from Ottawa philanthropist Bertram Loeb. “Critics suggested that Ms. Whitton, a product of a generation that opposed the immigration of Jewish refugees fleeing Hitler, simply didn’t want the name of a Jewish family on an Ottawa hospital building,” the Ottawa Citizen wrote in Loeb’s obituary.

Despite her racism, Whitton is still celebrated as the first female mayor of a major Canadian city. In 1967, she received an Order of Canada, before being elevated to Commander of the British Empire (CBE). There also exists a plaque in her honour in Ottawa, on Green Island, erected by the Ontario Heritage Foundation. Recently, a recommendation has been made by the Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada to Parks Canada to recognize Whitton as a person of “national historical significance.”

Ruth Klein, National Director of the League for Human Rights of B’nai Brith Canada, offered Shalom Life a statement about the praise that Whitton has received. “The Charlotte Whitton controversy forces us to re-evaluate the standards we use to choose our national heroes and heroines. Ms. Whitton has already received many honours, including the Order of Canada, but she was not alone in her efforts to close the doors to Jewish refugees from Hitler’s Europe at a time when their need for sanctuary was the greatest. We should remember it was Mackenzie King’s Liberal Government that refused pleas to let the St. Louis land in Canada in 1939. People’s prejudices and the actions they take should be taken into account when we assess their enduring legacy. The negatives cannot just be overlooked.”

Whitton’s newest honour “is long past due,” says Patricia Rooke, who co-authored a 1987 biography of Whitton, called No Bleeding Heart. To Rooke, this honour should have been given long ago to Whitton, who Rooke has also described as “a racist.” Rooke revealed another nationality, of which Whitton did not favour. “Her anti-Semitism, I think, was the least of it. She was quite racist about the Ukrainians, for example. She really didn’t like the changing character of Canadian society.”

Whitton, like many people during her time, was an anti-Semite, and for this reason there are those who feel she should not be judged based on today’s standards of society. However to Farber, the issue of her racism goes far beyond her mere views. “There were many people back then who were anti-Semitic, and held anti-Semitic views. If that was just the case [with Whitton], one could possibly overlook it,” said Farber.

“The difference with Charlotte Whitton is she acted on her anti-Semitic views. By acting on it, she damned Jewish children, and as a result those Jewish children were not able to seek shelter here. It’s her acting on her anti-Semitic views that is the issue, not that she held anti-Semitic views.”

Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men TrendingCanadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo Canadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo TrendingSeven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot Seven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot Trending
 

Israeli Makes Eurovision Finals for First Time in 5 Years

May 22, 2015 | By Shaleni McBain
Israeli Makes Eurovision Finals for First Time in 5 Years

'Golden Boy' Nadav Guedj hopes to live up to his name

Read More

Israeli Companies Make Gartner's Innovative 'Cool Vendors' List

May 22, 2015 | By Einat Paz-Frankel, NoCamels
Israeli Companies Make Gartner's Innovative 'Cool Vendors' List

18 out of 350 companies selected by leading American IT research firm Gartner are from the Holy Land

Read More

Jewish Community Center Cancels Marijuana Art Classes

May 22, 2015 | By Shaleni McBain
Jewish Community Center Cancels Marijuana Art Classes

Class that welcomed cannabis usage at Aspen Community Center in Colorado quickly nixed

Read More

Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men

May 22, 2015 | By Shaleni McBain
Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men

Country ranks #7 on the happiness index

Read More

Canadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo

May 22, 2015 | By Daniel Koren
Canadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo

Yehuda Danzig of Toronto was stunned when he came across a pic of himself and his younger brother while reading The Times of Israel

Read More

Seven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot

May 22, 2015 | By Maayan Jaffe, JNS.org
Seven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot

Here are a few ways to infuse some meaning and minhag (tradition) into your Shavuot this year

Read More

WATCH: Israeli, Muslim Footballers Unite For "One World, One Ball"

May 22, 2015 | By Daniel Koren
WATCH: Israeli, Muslim Footballers Unite For "One World, One Ball"

"Play the ball, not the state," say soccer players of various ethnicities to FIFA in new video

Read More

Obama: Our Commitment to Israel is Unshakeable

May 22, 2015 | By Daniel Koren
Obama: Our Commitment to Israel is Unshakeable

The U.S. President also spoke of the need a two-state solution on the inaugural "Solidarity Sabbath" in D.C.

Read More

More Headlines