Shalom Life | May 24, 2015

Israeli Orchestra Plays Hitler's Favourite Composer

An Israeli Orchestra played Wagner at the Beyreuth Festival, a favourite of Adolf Hitler's

By: Nelly Lalany

Published: July 28th, 2011 in News » World

Israeli Orchestra Plays Hitler's Favourite Composer

On Tuesday night, an Israeli orchestra took to the stage to play one of Richard Wagner’s compositions at the renowned Bayreuth Festival in Berlin. Sounds like an enjoyable night at the symphony, until you remember that Wagner was one of Hitler’s favorite composers and “Siegfried Idyll” (the piece being played) was written when Wagner’s second wife, Cosima, gave birth to their son Siegfried in 1869.

Hitler’s great adoration of Wagner’s compositions stemmed from their personal relationship. Hitler was Wagner’s muse, and likewise, Hitler was compelled by the composer’s anti-Semitic tributes claiming that Jews were corrupt.

Interestingly, Wagner founded the Bayreuth Festival in 1876, and Hitler was a major advocate (obviously due to the gratuitous brown nosing) who attended every summer from 1933-1939.

It seems that the issue is not that Wagner’s composition was played, but that it was an Israeli band that played it. After all, he did found the festival. Some people are quite outraged by it, and Elan Steinberg, deputy head of the American Gathering of Holocaust Survivors and their Descendants says,

“A disgraceful abandonment of solidarity with those who suffered at the hand of the Nazis.”

Steinberg’s message is understandable, but yet it is the Israeli band that felt justified in not only playing at a festival founded by Wagner, but also playing his music. Perhaps, this is a step forward in solidarity rather than a step back.

It is an overwhelming task to take on especially with the expectation of intense backlash, and deserves some sort of optimism.

Roberto Paternostro, conductor of the Israel Chamber Orchestra, who’s mother was a survivor of the Nazi genocide, defended the performance and said quite shockingly and simply, "Wagner's ideology and anti-Semitism was terrible, but on the other hand he was a great composer.”

The controversy isn’t exactly a new development; other Israeli orchestras have performed Wagner’s music in previous years.

In 2001, Daniel Barenboim decided to conduct a piece called, “Tristan and Isolde” in Israel. A bold move, which lead to many members of the audience leaving the theatre.

Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men TrendingCanadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo Canadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo TrendingSeven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot Seven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot Trending
 

Israeli Makes Eurovision Finals for First Time in 5 Years

May 22, 2015 | By Shaleni McBain
Israeli Makes Eurovision Finals for First Time in 5 Years

'Golden Boy' Nadav Guedj hopes to live up to his name

Read More

Israeli Companies Make Gartner's Innovative 'Cool Vendors' List

May 22, 2015 | By Einat Paz-Frankel, NoCamels
Israeli Companies Make Gartner's Innovative 'Cool Vendors' List

18 out of 350 companies selected by leading American IT research firm Gartner are from the Holy Land

Read More

Jewish Community Center Cancels Marijuana Art Classes

May 22, 2015 | By Shaleni McBain
Jewish Community Center Cancels Marijuana Art Classes

Class that welcomed cannabis usage at Aspen Community Center in Colorado quickly nixed

Read More

Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men

May 22, 2015 | By Shaleni McBain
Israel in Top 10 Countries for Gay Men

Country ranks #7 on the happiness index

Read More

Canadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo

May 22, 2015 | By Daniel Koren
Canadian Holocaust Survivor Recognizes Himself in Online Photo

Yehuda Danzig of Toronto was stunned when he came across a pic of himself and his younger brother while reading The Times of Israel

Read More

Seven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot

May 22, 2015 | By Maayan Jaffe, JNS.org
Seven Ways to Celebrate a Meaningful Shavuot

Here are a few ways to infuse some meaning and minhag (tradition) into your Shavuot this year

Read More

WATCH: Israeli, Muslim Footballers Unite For "One World, One Ball"

May 22, 2015 | By Daniel Koren
WATCH: Israeli, Muslim Footballers Unite For "One World, One Ball"

"Play the ball, not the state," say soccer players of various ethnicities to FIFA in new video

Read More

Obama: Our Commitment to Israel is Unshakeable

May 22, 2015 | By Daniel Koren
Obama: Our Commitment to Israel is Unshakeable

The U.S. President also spoke of the need a two-state solution on the inaugural "Solidarity Sabbath" in D.C.

Read More

More Headlines