Shalom Life | January 29, 2015

United Church Votes to Boycott Israeli Settlement Products

CIJA outraged by decision, which they say deters peace process

By: Sammy Hudes

Published: August 16th, 2012 in News » World

United Church Votes to Boycott Israeli Settlement Products

The General Council of the United Church of Canada (UCC), the country’s largest Protestant denomination, voted Wednesday to support a motion calling for a boycott of products produced in Israeli settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem.

The vote all but approved the resolution, as the final vote is now scheduled for Friday, when the General Council can choose to accept or reject an overall motion that includes such recommendations.

Members in attendance at the 41st General Council, which took place at Carleton University in Ottawa, Ont., debated the proposal for roughly six hours as representatives from both sides of the issue gave their testimonies, according to the Toronto Star.

The proposed boycott was initially put forward by a working group, appointed by the UCC, who spent two years studying ways to address the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

“In choosing this morally reckless path, the United Church has equally dismissed the concerns of the overwhelming majority of the Canadian Jewish community. No mainstream Jewish organization, including Canadian Friends of Peace Now, endorses Boycott. Even the leadership of the American left-wing group J-Street has publicly condemned boycotts as counterproductive,” said David Koschitzky, chair of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA), in a press release.

“Support for the boycott tactic is limited to a small fringe. Tragically, the UCC chose to join that fringe, rather than listen to the nearly 100,000 families who are members of Jewish Federations across Canada, and on whose behalf the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs speaks. The Church equally ignored some 70 Canadian Rabbis of all streams and from every province, representing tens of thousands of Canadian Jewish families, who made their opposition known in writing.”

The proposal is one of about 130 that commissioners have been discussing this week. The General Council meets every three years to elect a new church moderator and approve new policies, according to the National Post.

In July, nine Canadian senators, all of whom are United Church members and a mix of both Conservatives and Liberals, sent a letter to the UCC condemning the proposed boycott for being too one-sided. The senators indicated that they were concerned their denomination has now lost credibility in its role as a concerned third party in the Middle East conflict.

“It’s baffling that — aside from a passing request that all parties reject violence — the Church’s [proposal] does not mention a single expectation of the Palestinians in its recommendations,” the letter stated. “To put it bluntly, the Church cannot maintain credibility in criticizing Israeli policies while relieving the Palestinian leadership of its own duty to advance peace.”

In response to the letter, Bruce Gregersen, lead staff member of the working group that produced the resolution, wrote back to the senators explaining that while the UCC appreciated the concern shown for the church’s relationship with the Canadian Jewish community, choosing to “remain neutral in respect to the difficult realities of the region is not acceptable after 45 years of continued occupation.”

Following Wednesday’s vote, Gregersen called it a “significant step” towards a full approval of the boycott by the UCC.

“The mind of the council is pretty clear. The main recommendations were approved by a fairly overwhelming vote,” said Gregersen, noting that he does not believe the proposal to be anti-Israel.

“We are solidly behind Israel as a legitimate Jewish state. We don’t want to demonize in any way Israel or Jewish people,” he said. “The problem is the occupation and the settlements.”

But CIJA CEO Shimon Fogel condemned the proposal, calling its near-approval an “outrage” to Canada’s Jewish community.

“The reaction of the Jewish community is one of unbridled outrage. It is beyond comprehension that [the UCC] would choose to so skew a commentary on the conflict and come out with so one-sided an approach,” said Fogel.

Anti-Israel BDS Movement May Be Fashionable in Academia, But It's Far From Invincible Anti-Israel BDS Movement May Be Fashionable in Academia, But It's Far From Invincible TrendingArtist Envisions The Simspons as Jews During the Holocaust Artist Envisions The Simspons as Jews During the Holocaust TrendingUnaired Hitchcock Holocaust Film Finally Shown on HBO Unaired Hitchcock Holocaust Film Finally Shown on HBO Trending
 

Chelsea Handler is Topless on Camel Wearing Israeli Flag Pasties

January 29, 2015 | By Ashley Baylen
Chelsea Handler is Topless on Camel Wearing Israeli Flag Pasties

Handler's "free the nipple" campaign continues this time in Israel.

Read More

Roseanne Barr For Next Season of ‘Dancing With The Stars’?

January 29, 2015 | By Ashley Baylen
Roseanne Barr For Next Season of ‘Dancing With The Stars’?

The comedian is considering appearing on the 20th season of ABC's dancing competition.

Read More

Netflix Secures Original ‘Wet Hot American Summer’ Cast For New Series [VIDEO]

January 29, 2015 | By Ashley Baylen
Netflix Secures Original ‘Wet Hot American Summer’ Cast For New Series [VIDEO]

Paul Rudd, Elizabeth Banks, and Amy Poehler returning for the upcoming series.

Read More

Adam Lambert Announces Album Title

January 29, 2015 | By Ashley Baylen
Adam Lambert Announces Album Title

'The Original High' was announced on Lambert's 33rd birthday.

Read More

Getting anti-Semitism Wrong at the United Nations

January 29, 2015 | By Ben Cohen, JNS.org
 Getting anti-Semitism Wrong at the United Nations

It's hard to think of another body that would organize a special meeting on the subject of rising anti-Semitism with anti-Semites not just in attendance, but making speeches as well

Read More

Israelis Develop 3D Metal Printer

January 29, 2015 | By NoCamels Team
Israelis Develop 3D Metal Printer

The revolutionary 3-D printing system is the first of its kind in Israel

Read More

Thousands Arrive at Funerals for Soldiers Killed in Hezbollah Attack

January 29, 2015 | By Gilad Morag
Thousands Arrive at Funerals for Soldiers Killed in Hezbollah Attack

Maj. Yochai Kalangel buried on Mount Herzl, while Staff-Sgt. Dor Nini is being laid to rest in Moshav Shtulim

Read More

EXCLUSIVE: Nancy Spielberg Talks New Documentary ‘Above and Beyond’

January 28, 2015 | By Ashley Baylen
EXCLUSIVE: Nancy Spielberg Talks New Documentary ‘Above and Beyond’

'Above and Beyond' is the first major feature-length documentary about the foreign airmen in the 1948 Arab-Israeli War.

Read More

More Headlines